Season 1

Dec. 17, 2021

Season Finale: The Lawson Christmas Massacre

First and foremost we want to thank the When Killers Get Caught Podcast community. We had no idea when we started things that we'd get to a place where we are at the end of our first year podcasting. You …

Episode page
Dec. 9, 2021

Robert The Doll- Always say goodbye

As you can probably tell from the title, this is a Brian heavy episode this week. Brittany is out sick so we leave it up to the creepy guy to talk about things. This week in true crime Brian tells …

Episode page
Dec. 3, 2021

Ronald Eugene Simmons and the Mockingbird Hill Massacre

This week we discuss our end of year holiday schedule and new merch for our podcastiversary! This week in true crime: Brittany is shocked that two suspected teen murderers have the audacity to ask to go home for Christmas. Br...

Episode page
Nov. 18, 2021

Charles Cullen claimed he was "helping"

This week we discuss an update on our schedule and fun changes for 2022! This week in true crime: Brittany learned of several naked men are bothering people in Central Pennsylvania and Brian discusses a man at a PA college …

Episode page
Nov. 11, 2021

Charles Ng, Leonard Lake & the mystery 45 pounds of bone fragment

Sources for this podcast: Die For Me: The Terrifying Story of Charles Ng/Leonard Lake Torture Murders by Don Lasseter The Sex Slave Murders 3: The Horrific Tale of Serial Killers Leonard Lake & Charles Ng Book 3 of 3: The …

Episode page
Nov. 4, 2021

Gary Ridgway Part II: The Hunt to find a monster

Sources for this episode: PUBLISHED: JUNE 14, 2021 UPDATED: AUGUST 17, 2021 The Childhood of the Green River Killer, Gary Ridgway ADAM JANOS Ridgway gave no hint he was a killer, son said Dec 23, 2003 By Michael Ko …

Episode page
Oct. 28, 2021

Gary Ridgway: Part I, The Mask that fooled far too many

Sources for this episode: PUBLISHED: JUNE 14, 2021 UPDATED: AUGUST 17, 2021 The Childhood of the Green River Killer, Gary Ridgway ADAM JANOS Ridgway gave no hint he was a killer, son said Dec 23, 2003 By Michael Ko …

Episode page
Oct. 21, 2021

Andrew Kehoe and the Bath, Michigan Massacre

This week in True Crime: Brittany needs to know more about a missing Alabama woman whose remains were found in a cop van and Brian tells the sad tale of a woman who killed a man because he wouldn't kiss …

Episode page
Oct. 14, 2021

Episode 37: The Inescapable madness of Carl Panzram

Sources for this episode: The Panzram Papers by Carl Panzram and John Borowski Killer: A Journal of Murder Hardcover Thomas E. Gaddis and James O. Long Panzram : Butchering Humanity: An Autobiography Paperback – August 30, 2020 by Mr Carl …

Episode page
Oct. 7, 2021

Episode 36: The Osage Nation Serial Murders that legitimized the FBI

Sources for this episode: Killers of the Flower Moon: The Osage Murders and the Birth of the FBI by David Grann The Deaths of Sybil Bolton: Oil, Greed, and Murder on the Osage Reservation by Dennis McAuliffe Bill Burchardt, "Osage …

Episode page
Sept. 30, 2021

Episode 35: Katherine Knight: Cannibal? Murderer? Really Bad Girlfrie…

Sources for this episode: Beyond Bad: The Life and Crimes of Katherine Knight, Australia's Hannibal Kindle Edition by Sandra Lee Blood Stain Kindle Edition by Peter Lalor Lady Cannibal: The True Story of Katherine Knight Book by Natalie Marshall Man-Eater: …

Episode page
Sept. 23, 2021

Robert Hansen, a man with a serious love of hunting… people

The Sources for this episode: The Butcher Baker: The True Story of Robert Hansen The Human Hunter by Genoveva Ortiz and True Crime Seven The Butcher Baker: The Search for Alaskan Serial Killer Robert Hansen by Reagan Martin Butcher, Baker: …

Episode page
Sept. 16, 2021

Episode 33: The obsessive occult motherly love of Leonarda Cianciulli…

The Sources for this episode: Leonarda Cianciulli: The Soap-Maker of Correggio: Serial Killer Chronicles #1 by F. Amos Hurt The Curse: A Shocking True Story of Superstition, Human Sacrifice and Cannibalism by Ryan Green Killer Moms: 16 Bizarre True Crime …

Episode page
Sept. 9, 2021

Episode 32: The Shifting Murderous Moods of Nannie Doss

The sources for this episode: The Mammoth Book of True Crime by Colin Wilson "Nannie Doss - Encyclopedia of Alabama". Encyclopedia of Alabama. Black Widow: The True Story of Giggling Granny Nannie Doss by Ryan Green The Giggling Granny: Serial …

Episode page
Sept. 2, 2021

Episode 31. The SCP Foundation and Things You Shouldn't Mess With

It's lone wolf time! That's right Brittany is on vacation and has left you solely in the hands of your creepy friend Brian. This week in true crime, Brian discusses some childhood wants. Then Brian tells you about some of …

Episode page
Aug. 26, 2021

Episode 30: Herb Baumeister & the 5,000 bone fragments on Fox Hollow …

Sources: You Think You Know Me: The True Story of Herb Baumeister and the Horror at Fox Hollow Farm by Ryan Green The Double Life of a Serial Murderer: The Life of Serial Killer Herb Baumeister by Jack Smith Historic …

Episode page
Aug. 19, 2021

Episode 29: Gertrude Baniszewski; the Monster Mom of Indianapolis

Sources for this episode: Mistresses of mayhem : the book of women criminals By Francine LaSala/Hornberger Torture Mom – Ryan Green House of Evil: The Indiana Torture Slaying Part of: St. Martin's True Crime Library by John Dean The Darkest …

Episode page
Aug. 12, 2021

Episode 28: Dorothea Puente was a landlord from hell

Source List: Human harvest: the Sacramento murder story By Blackburn, Daniel The bone garden by William P. Wood Mistresses of mayhem: the book of women criminals by Francine LaSala (Hornberger) Disturbed Ground - by Carla Norton Deadlier Than the Male …

Episode page
Aug. 5, 2021

Episode 27: Richard Speck & The Townhouse Massacre

Brittany's Sources: Born to raise hell; the untold story of Richard Speck By Jack Altman and Marvin Ziporyn The Crime of the Century by Dennis L. Breo The Crime of the Century: Richard Speck and the Murders That Shocked a …

Episode page
July 29, 2021

Episode 26: Jim Jones: Prophet? Unlikely. Mass murderer? Definitely.

Sources: Guyana massacre : the eyewitness account by Krause, Charles A; Stern, Laurence M. (Laurence Marcus), 1929-1979; Harwood, Richard; Johnston, Frank, 1941- Jonestown FBI Files Jonestown, FBI, Federal Bureau of Investigation, FOIA, Freedom of Information, Freedom of Information Act The …

Episode page
July 22, 2021

Episode 25. Elizabeth Bathory: All That Land and Still Got Caught

Sources: Infamous Lady: The True Story of Countess Erzsébet Báthory: Second Edition by Kimberly L. Craft Baring-Gould, Sabine. The Book of Werewolves. London: Smith, Elder, 1865. Codrescu, Andrei. The Blood Countess. New York: Simon & Schuster, 1995. Everitt, David. Human …

Episode page
July 15, 2021

Episode 24. Earl Nelson: Boarding Houses Beware

Sources: Baeza, J. & Turvey, B., "Sadistic Behavior: A Literature Review," Knowledge Solutions Library, Electronic Publication, May, 1999. Douglas, John E. and Mark Olshaker, The Anatomy of Motive : The FBI's Legendary Mindhunter Explores the Key to Understanding and Catching …

Episode page
July 1, 2021

Episode 23. Ed Gein: Don't Let Him Decorate Your Home

Source: Edward Gein, America's most bizarre murderer By Gollmar, Robert H., 1903- Deviant : the shocking true story of the original 'psycho' By Schechter, Harold

Episode page
June 24, 2021

Episode 22: Prosenjit Poddar’s obsession over a classmate changed US …

Source: Bad Karma: A True Story of Obsession and Murder Book by Deborah Blum Stalking, Erotomania, and the Tarasoff Cases Glenn S. Lipson, Ph.D. and Mark J. Mills, J.D., M.D.

Episode page
June 17, 2021

Episode 21: The Frustrating Case of the Solved but Unsolved Frankford…

Source: The primary source for this piece was the coverage in the Philadelphia Inquirer, August 1985 – July 2000, along with supplements from the following books. Mendoza, Antonio. Killers on the Loose: Unsolved Cases of Serial Murder. Revised and updated. …

Episode page
June 10, 2021

Episode 20: A VERY Short history of the killer of killers: Pedro Rodr…

This week Brittany is podcasting alone because life kicks us all in the butt sometimes. First on the docket is a woman who got arrested for pretending to be her daughter at school and then a small history of the …

Episode page
May 20, 2021

Episode 19. Andrea Yates: Strangely Sympathetic and Local Legends

Sources: "Andrea Yates," Mugshots, Court TV, 2003. Flock, Jeff. "Chilling Details of the Houston Child Killings." CNN.Com. June 22, 2001. "Interview: Dr. Dietz," Time, May 19, 2002. "Juries Often Spare Mothers Who Kill,", June 28, 2001. McCalope, Michelle. "Rusty …

Episode page
May 13, 2021

Episode 18: Amy Bishop, the murderous academic

Sources: A Professor's Rage: The Chilling True Story of Harvard PhD Amy Bishop, her Brother's Mysterious Death, and the Shooting Spree that Shocked the Nation by Michele R. McPhee Murder Untenured, Amy Bishop's Rampage by Jacquelyn Procter Reeves

Episode page
May 6, 2021

Episode 17: The Murder of Ken Rex McElroy and the Cold Case no one co…

Sources: Books In Broad Daylight: A Murder in Skidmore, Missouri, Harry N. MacLean, Dell, 1988 Judgment Day, Bob Lancaster and B.C. Hall, Seaview/Putnam, 1983 Articles "Suspects Are Legion in Slaying of a Missouri 'Town Bully,'" By Jules Loh, The Associated …

Episode page
April 29, 2021

Episode 16. Harold Shipman: Don't Let Him Near Your Parents

Sources: Prescription for Murder: The True Story of Dr Harold Frederick ... Book by Brian Whittle and Jean Ritchie Harold Shipman: Mind Set on Murder : why Shipman Killed and ... Book by Carol Talbert Peters Evil Beyond Belief - …

Episode page
April 22, 2021

Episode 15.5: Brian Tries His Best

This week is a little different. Time constraints and life happen which led us to this episode. Brian talks about crazy Uber passengers and takes us on another trip to West Virginia to talk more about cryptids. You can get …

Episode page
April 15, 2021

Episode 15: Jesse Pomeroy, a teenage nightmare for South Boston

Sources: Making a Monster: Jesse Pomeroy, the Boy Murderer of 1870s Dawn Keetley Selections From The Writings Of Jesse Harding Pomeroy: Life Prisoner Since 1874 by Jesse Harding Pomeroy "The Boy Murderer" April 24, 1874. Bousfield, Richard M. and Richard …

Episode page
April 8, 2021

Episode 14: The Beast of the Ukraine is no match for a worried dad

Sources: Terminator: The True Story of Anatoly Onoprienko Jasmine Brett An Encyclopedia of Modern Serial Killers – Hunting Humans, by Michael Newton Various Newspapers: St.Peterburg Times – Russia BBC News – UK The Guardian – UK London Times – UK …

Episode page
April 1, 2021

Episode 13: Herbert Mullen: How many People Did You Need To Sacrifice?

Sources: Deadly Voices: The True Story of Serial Killer Herbert Mullin by C.L. Swinney The Die Song by Donald Lunde and L Morgan Jefferson Murder and Madness by Donald Lunde

Episode page
March 25, 2021

Episode 12: The Narcosatanicos try to conjure demons and the Warrens …

Sources Evil Serial Killers: In the Minds of Monsters – Charlotte Greig Buried Secrets” A true story Drug Running, Black Magic and Human Sacrifice– Edward Humes (1991) Buried Secrets: A true story of serial murder – Edward Humes (2014)

Episode page
March 18, 2021

Episode 11: Phoolan Devi, The Bandit Queen & America’s Favorite Demon…

Source for Phoolan Devi: The Bandit Queen of India: An Indian Woman's Amazing Journey From Peasant to International Legend by Phoolan Devi, Marie-Therese Cuny and Paul Rambali. I, Phoolan Devi : The Autobiography of India's Bandit Queen by Phoolan Devi

Episode page
March 18, 2021

Our Story

Brittany and Brian talk about who they are and how they got into true crime and studying the supernatural. You can get extra content on TikTok @caughtpodcast and @creepswithbrian to get your killer fix during the week. You ca...

Episode page
March 11, 2021

Episode 10: Yoo Yeong-Chul ; one man and his hammer

Sources for Yoo Yeong-Chul The majority of the sources were from news articles as there is only one book about this Killer. Sal In Joong Ma (English title: Murder Addiction) by Lee Eun-Young. The author exchanged thirty letters with Yoo …

Episode page
March 4, 2021

Episode 9: Ivan Milat, The Backpack Killer and Death By Snu Snu

Sources on Ivan Milat Sins of the Brother by Mark Whittaker and Les Kennedy Fate by Neil Mercer Several newspapers including The Sydney Morning Herald and the Australian also provided extensive coverage of the case.

Episode page
Feb. 25, 2021

Episode 8: The Moors Murders and Some Spooky Spaghetti

Sources used for the Moors Murders Podcast Myra Hindley—Inside the Mind of a Murderess by Jean Ritchie The Moors Murders: The Trial of Myra Hindley and Ian Brady by Jonathan Goodman One Of Your Own: The Life and Death of …

Episode page
Feb. 18, 2021

Episode 7: Ray and Faye Copeland, Leave The Cattle Alone Dude

Sources for Ray and Fay Copeland Episode The Copeland Killings by Tom Miller. Family Bones by Shawn Granger The Naturals by Jennifer Lynn Barnes Evil Serial Killers: In the Minds of Monsters by Charlotte Greig The True Story of Ray …

Episode page
Feb. 11, 2021

Episode 6: The Lonely Hearts Killers, Spreading Love The Wrong Way

Sources on The Lonely Hearts Killers The Honeymoon Killers by Paul Beck Condemned: Inside the Sing Sing Death House by Scott Christianson The Lonely Hearts Killers(Introduction to Murder) by Wenzell Brown The Encyclopedia of American Crime by Carl Sifakis Newspaper …

Episode page
Feb. 4, 2021

Episode 5: A match made in hell: Paul Bernardo and Karla Hamolka

Sources on Paul Bernardo and Karla Hamolka Karla: A Pact with the Devil by Stephen Williams Lethal Marriage: The Uncensored Truth Behind the Crimes of Paul Bernardo and Karla Homolka by Nick Pron Female Serial Killers: How and Why Women …

Episode page
Jan. 28, 2021

Episode 4: Belle Gunness, Life Insurance Collector and The Mystery of…

Sources on Belle Gunness The Truth About Belle Gunness by Lillian de la Torre Evil Serial Killers: In the Minds of Monsters by Charlotte Gregg The Serial Killer Files The Who , What, Where, How and why of the Worlds …

Episode page
Jan. 21, 2021

Episode 3: H. H. Holmes, Lying, Dying, and somehow had three wives

Sources on H.H.Holmes The Devil in the White City: Murder, Magic and Madness at the Fair the Changed America by Erik Larson The Strange Life of H.H. Holmes by Debra Pawlak

Episode page
Jan. 14, 2021

Episode 2: Madame Delphine LaLaurie Sadly No Voodoo Queen

Sources for Madame Delphine LaLaurie Madame Lalaurie, Mistress of the Haunted House by Carolyn Morrow Long Restropect of Western Travel by Harriet Martineu (1838). Mad Madame LaLaurie: New Orleans' Most Famous Murderess Revealed By Victoria Cosner Love and Lorelei Shannon

Episode page
Jan. 7, 2021

Episode 1: Dr.Marcel Petiot , The fake nazi killer of World War II

Sources on Dr. Petiot The Unspeakable Crimes of Dr. Petiot by Thomas Maeder The Great Liquidator by John Grombach Murder in France by Alister Kershaw Death In the City of Light by David King

Episode page